Law · Legal Information · Justice
 

Evidence

Proof of fact(s) presented at a judicial hearing such as a trial.

Proof of fact(s) presented at a trial.

Neatly divided into the most prevalent, direct evidence, and the slightly more difficult, circumstantial evidence.

A judge, at the commencement of a trial, is like an empty scale - the scales of justice!

She knows nothing at that point so the scale is perfectly balanced.

It is up to the two opposing sides to teeter the scale one way or another with evidence so that at the end of the hearing, she can determine what the truth likely is and can render judgment on a preponderance of what she's heard or seen: the evidence.

Evidence pixThe best and most common method is by oral or viva voce testimony; where you have an eye-witness swear to tell the truth and to then relate to the court (or jury) their experience.

Evidence is the ways and means used to persuade the judge or jury of your facts as the judge (or jury) is expected to start off with a blank slate; no preconceived idea or knowledge of the facts.

So it is up to the opposing parties to prove (by providing evidence), to the satisfaction of the court (or jury), the facts needed to support their respective cases.

In a civil suit, the plaintiff has the burden of proof so in the event of a tie in the evidence, the plaintiff loses.

In a criminal trial, the burden (a different burden: beyond a reasonable doubt), is on the prosecutor.

Besides oral testimony, an object or document can be deposited with the court (eg. a signed contract). This is an example of direct evidence, sometimes called "real evidence."

Sometimes, the evidence can be things or events from which conclusions can be drawn, such as Justice Pennefather's example in Harvey v Church, a footprint in the sand is evidence that someone has been walking there.

In other rarer cases, evidence can be circumstantial.

REFERENCES:

Harvey v Church 17 NZLR 19 (1898)


Are we missing anything? If you think there is a term that should be included, please send us the suggestion

  • Dictionary
  • Resources
  • LawMag

Latest LagMag headlines:

H1N1 Law - Swine Law for a Swine Flu

In a state of public health law anarchy, professional hockey players receive a killer flu vaccine while infants and pregnant women wait.

More...

The Death of the Common Law: Expiry date, 2100

Just about now, but for the economic might of the United States of America, the last funeral bell tolls of the common law would be fading.

More...

Gretzky Law

The recent Phoenix Coyotes debacle, in which he left behind his job, is not the only time Wayne Gretzky has had to leave from the side exit of a courtroom.

More...


Read earlier headlines »
Subscribe to stay in touch »

Unless otherwise noted, this article was written by Lloyd Duhaime, Barrister, Solicitor, Attorney and Lawyer (and Notary Public!). It is not intended to be legal advice and you would be foolhardy to rely on it in respect to any specific situation you or an acquaintance may be facing. In addition, the law changes rapidly and sometimes with little notice so from time to time, an article may not be up to date. Therefore, this is merely legal information designed to educate the reader. If you have a real situation, this information will serve as a good springboard to get legal advice from a lawyer.

top